How operators are squeezing profits from water

Earls water

"Our carbonated soft drink sales at Earls.67 reflect a national trend; we’re continually down on carbonated soft drink sales by 8% to 9% on an annual basis at all Earls locations,” says Cameron Bogue, beverage director at the contemporary-casual chain Earls Kitchen + Bar.

About three in 10 consumers are increasingly drinking water at restaurants instead of other beverages for health reasons, shows Technomic’s Beverage Consumer Trend Report. However, many seem to be choosing tap water over bottled water for cost reasons.

In response, Earls.67—a prototype of Earls Kitchen + Bar in Calgary, Alberta—started testing a new idea last summer: housemade carbonated waters in flavors such as guava and celery, cola, and pineapple star anise. The flavored waters are priced at $2 per glass and do not come with free refills.

It’s obvious from the presentation that this isn’t just tap water. We add a garnish to the flavored waters that make them look like a one-time buy, and we’ve never been questioned by guests about it,” says Bogue. The garnishes match the waters—for instance, the celery iteration features a spiralized celery ribbon—and also prevent staffers from accidentally pouring tap water into the glass, says Bogue.

The problem with spa water

Execs who travel a lot have likely run across spa water: that jug of fruit-infused water in a hotel lobby. Many restaurateurs are intrigued with the offering, but at this point, they are learning that infused water can’t be offered at a cost to guests unless there is added value beyond cut-up fruit.

Bogue says, “I was adamant that I didn’t want to charge for spa water. Our infused-water lineup needed to be more valuable, made with extracts, distillates and good garnishes.”

Beverage Director Mat Snapp, who is considering adding a similar option to his self-serve drinks at Fox Restaurant Concepts’ fast casual Flower Child this summer, agrees. “We have to make sure that the value perception is there. You need to offer some specific benefit or flavor component that someone wants to buy,” he says. 

Agua fresca alternatives 

At the original location of Beefsteak, Jose Andres’ fast casual in Washington, D.C., water infused with cucumber and basil sits out for guests to help themselves to—but it’s free. Pat Peterson, Beefsteak’s executive chef, says, “It just doesn’t make sense to charge for it. Guests love it, but they don’t see the value in packing up some veggies and throwing it into a water tower.” This particular water isn’t too costly for the veggie-focused restaurant, as it is able to use its leftover veggie pieces from service in the water. 

Still, charging for it has been a challenge for him, too. Peterson has found success at some other Beefsteak family restaurants by positioning an infused water as an agua fresca as opposed to flavored water. It’s a way to enhance the value perception and be able to charge guests, he says. In addition to appealing to health-conscious consumers, he adds, the drinks are a middle-of-the-road option that allow operators to offer a lower price point than craft sodas. 

“Look at your entry-level entree price and your workhorse in your beverage program, and try to keep [the signature water option] in the 20%-30% price range of the entree … Anything above is risky,” says Peterson. “There’s a great craft soda out there that costs a lot—$4.50—and when we’re charging $8.50 for a bowl, proportionately that doesn’t make sense.” But the higher the quality of the ingredients used, the higher the cost per ounce, he adds. “It’s a balancing act.”

Today's top stories

After closing its Teavana tea cafes, Starbucks is shutting down the retail component of the business as well, with plans to close all 379 Teavana retail stores within a year. “Many of the company’s...
Recently, delivery-only or virtual restaurants have increased in popularity , especially in major cities like New York, Chicago, and the Bay Area. With the rise in social media; a variety of high-...
With other restaurants whimpering about labor costs, Passport Pizza knows how sweet it is to be paid for hiring talent. “I love getting those $4,600 checks,” says Sue LaTour, president of the Detroit...
After sneering at fast food for decades, Chipotle has decided traditional quick-service chains may not be as brain-dead as it alleged. The home of Food with Integrity is showing a change of heart...
When it comes to flavoring foods, chefs and home cooks alike rely on a few staples: acids, salts, fats and of course, spices and herbs. Spices and herbs can bring heat to an otherwise ordinary dish,...
Taco Bell is partnering with Lyft to allow customers to grab late-night tacos while using the car ride service. A function of the Lyft app, Taco Mode, enables users to request a stop at a Taco Bell...
Aggressive discontinuing and simultaneous promotion of a new premium sandwich line added momentum during the second quarter to McDonald’s turnaround , with same-store sales for U.S. restaurants...
When opening a franchise, there are a lot of upfront costs that franchisees have to consider. Beyond the obvious such as food costs and labor, the cost of technology to help run the business—...
The Tijuana Flats fast-casual Tex-Mex chain is adding a family meal kit as a delivery option available from all 130 of its branches starting Monday. The $31.99 kit consists of a taco bar in portable...
The Beef ‘O’ Brady’s and The Brass Tap casual-dining chains have been sold by Levine Leichtman Capital Partners to CapitalSpring Partners, a New York City-based concern that specializes in the...