Joe’s Crab Shack chain tries no-tipping

joes crab shack crab legs

In what may be the first significant trial of a no-tipping policy by a full-service chain, Joe’s Crab Shack has switched the servers at 18 units to a set wage and alerted customers they no longer are expected to tip.

Servers will be paid a wage starting at $14 an hour, though the exact amount will vary from server to server on the basis of their past performance, according to the chain’s parent company, Ignite Restaurant Group.

The money to pay the waiters and waitresses is being generated by a price increase of 12 percent to 15 percent, Ignite CEO Ray Blanchette told investors late last week.

He revealed that the test began in August but was still being rolled into some restaurants as recently as last Tuesday.

Ignite expects the switch to a wage to reduce server turnover. A $14 hourly wage sounds much better than $2.13, which is the wage they’d get, sans tips, at competing restaurants, noted Blanchette. It’s also a yellow light to servers who know they’ll likely start with the least-lucrative shifts if they move to another restaurant.

He also noted a wage model solves some service problems for Joe’s. Waiters and waitresses usually balk at having someone help them with a big table because then they have to split the tip. Joe’s, which has a number of large parties, won’t have to deal with that at the 18 test cites, said Blanchette.

He added that customers who tip generously may end up spending less for a meal than they previously did, since the price increases levied at the test store are less than 20 percent.

Blanchette said the test will likely run through the rest of the year, and there are no plans as yet to begin a similar trial in Ignite’s other restaurant holding, the Brick House sports-bar concept.

A number of high-profile independent restaurants have recently decided to replace tipping within their restaurants with a set wage for servers. Joe’s appears to be the first chain to try the switch.

“We’re really leading in our industry with regards to national brand going out and testing this thing in a meaningful way,” said Blanchette. “So we want to be somewhat cautious.”

Today's top stories

A 15.2% decline in traffic dragged down Chipotle’s same-store sales for the third quarter by 21.9%—a slight improvement from the 23.6% drop of the prior period , but proof the concept is still...
Technomic President Darren Tristano discusses restaurant concepts projected to grow in 2017.
Emeryville, Calif., has followed the lead of San Francisco and Seattle in requiring restaurateurs and other employers to set workers’ schedules at least two weeks in advance of a shift. The...
Hamish Dodds has resigned as president and CEO of Hard Rock International after nearly 13 years to pursue other opportunities starting early next year, the restaurant, lodging and casino company...
David G. Burke has succeeded Michael Ansley as CEO of Diversified Restaurant Holdings, a 64-unit Buffalo Wild Wings franchisee and parent of the Bagger Dave’s burger concept. Ansley, who founded the...
Two iconic hot dog stands are catching some of the buzz over this year’s baseball playoffs by waging a snarky Twitter battle over whose city has the better team—and taste in dogs. Putdowns of the Los...
Lemonade has hired Larry Kurzweil, a former CEO of Universal Studios Hollywood, as chief executive of the growing fast casual. Kurzweil replaces co-founder Alan Jackson, who has taken on the role of...
First, congratulations on what sounds like tremendous success! I’m very happy for you. My overall advice is harsh but simple: too late. You should have agreed to the terms of your new position before...
The operators of two Johnny Rockets restaurants in the Washington, D.C., area have agreed to pay $571,460 to servers who were required to share tips with back-of-the-house employees. The back wages...
Chefs are not just the leaders in the culinary industry. They’re also the leaders around key issues that affect the future of food. Chefs from around the country participated in the James Beard...