Is tipping at the tipping point?

tip dish large

It’s been about a year since Union Square Hospitality Group’s President and CEO Danny Meyer started implementing his no-tipping policy as a new mode of compensation. Tom Colicchio—owner of Craft, Craftsteak and others—was among the other restaurateurs who embraced the idea. But at this point, few others on the Top 100 list have.

“It’s an interesting idea,” says Michael Jacobs, partner at Corner Table Restaurants in New York City. “I understand what Danny’s trying to do, but I firmly believe the American consumer is not ready to adopt that component. In certain circumstances, it works. But we don’t foresee any changeover to a no-tipping policy in our business, just based on the way menu pricing will have to fall out afterwards. If we’re looking to be a value-oriented casual brasserie, I can’t have a $30 burger. Whether you’re going to tip or not, I think what the guest perceives is that it’s a $30 burger, not a $20 burger that includes a tip.”

Quality Branded founder and President Michael Stillman believes that there’s a global transition in the way people are being paid in restaurants, and it’s been coming for quite some time. It’s not without good reason, he says:  There’s definitely an imbalance between front-of-house and back-of-house service staff. “As I talk to restaurateurs, they believe the system is disjointed and there needs to be some sort of new model. But I think no one is sure what that is. We don’t want to hurt our front-of-house staff either.”

Today's top stories

1
While Asian fare, from Japanese noodle bowls to Korean fried chicken, is a huge hit with today’s consumers, its popularity is only going to continue to boom. Technomic’s 2017 Top 500 Chains...
2
Domino’s proved once again it’s dodging the sales slowdown hamstringing other restaurant operations, posting a 10.2% domestic same-store sales gain for the first quarter. The leap in sales follows a...
3
The Food and Drug Administration is pushing back enforcement of menu labeling requirements for chain restaurants and retailers from the scheduled start day of May 5, according to a group lobbying for...
4
Cash may still be king, but a huge asterisk is being slapped atop that truism as it applies to restaurants. The number of places looking to forgo currency and accept only cashless payments, and app-...
5
It is a commendable goal to look at performance metrics to make sure your employees are performing to their potential and have incentive to excel. On the surface, there is nothing preventing an...
6
Much like food trucks before them, food halls are the new go-to format for incubating a restaurant concept. Chef Andrew Gruel knows this well. Gruel’s California-based fast-casual sustainable fish...
7
After revealing dramatic indications that a sales rebound is underway , Chipotle acknowledged more misfortune yesterday, warning customers that some personal information may have been swiped by...
8
Chipotle proved today its recovery drive is finding traction , posting a same-store sales gain of 17.8% for the first quarter of 2017 and an expansion of store-level operating margins to 17.7%,...
9
With more consumers expressing an interest in “free-from” foods and wanting to know the origin of their next meal, operators across segments are taking a more transparent approach to menu creation...
10
Consumers continue to show interest in clean, natural ingredients on restaurant menus. It’s easy to see why: Mandatory nutrition labeling for chain restaurant menus has pushed the idea of...