All about that taste

We asked our Clean Plate Award judges what makes a winning dish, and they said a mouthful.

Bon Appetit’s Andrew Knowlton offered this peek into how he starts the process for picking the magazine’s Best Restaurants of the Year: “I have friends and professionals around the country who will email me when they have a positive experience at a place and encourage me to check it out.” We take a similar approach for our annual Clean Plates Awards, now in its eighth year. Our “friends and professionals” represent a cross section of our audience—foodies of the highest level who deliver and indulge in great-tasting meals both in their restaurants and in their busy work, traveling around the country scouting and opening restaurants and networking with employees, business partners and consumers. And they pick the winners.

So, what does it take for a dish to impress such a demanding panel? To answer that question, I used an online word-cloud tool to see what terms were used most often by our judges to describe this year’s winning dishes. For the nearly four dozen dishes submitted, their words revealed the following  insights about what makes a winner—in addition to the No. 1 factor: it’s just plain “delicious”:

It’s innovative. The Clean Plate Awards showcase plenty of ingenuity, with accolades going to chefs doing something no one else is doing, executing a classic dish better than anyone else or putting clever twists on dishes that even our skilled panel hadn’t experienced before.

It’s consistent. You might expect professional foodies to credit only the fanciest, most unique meals, but a number of our judges picked items from stops they visited again and again, where the food is executed perfectly every time.

It doesn’t try too hard. While all the winning dishes wowed, it often was their simplicity that stood out, judges said, because it let the true flavors shine.

Its presentation is creative. Several judges noted how a dish was served, not only how it tasted. No detail went unnoticed; Cinnabon President Kat Cole even praised one spot’s bread service.

To see how a crack panel of average, everyday paletes varied from our esteemed panel’s, the Restaurant Business staff offers our own picks for the best dishes of the year, here. In addition to anything drenched in butter, we were drawn to plates with similar criteria to the judges’. Nick Hayman, RB’s publisher, praised the Pave de Saumon Grille, a grilled salmon dish with lentils and Dijon-mustard sauce at Et Voila in Washington, D.C., as a “simple dish with great flavors.” The voice of RB’s Reality Check column, Peter Romeo, singled out Gene & Jude’s Chicago-style dog for being so good, he could weep. His second pick,  the pulled chicken at Piggyback Tavern in Forest Park, Ill., won for being “juicy, flavorful and plentiful enough to make me consider rolling around in it for awhile before finishing the meal.” Read more picks from the Restaurant Business staff, and tweet me your own to @RB_Magazine on Twitter. 

View the 2014 Clean Plate Awards

Today's top stories

1
The U.S. Department of Labor does specify how an unpaid internship can be legal , but most restaurant operations would either fail this test or have to significantly alter how they handle internships...
2
Dave Theno, one of the restaurant industry’s most prominent authorities on food safety, drowned Monday off the coast of Hawaii while swimming with his grandson, according to media reports . He was 66...
3
Sonic Drive-In plans to test a burger patty made with a blend of ground beef and mushrooms to reduce the meat content, a health initiative believed to be a first for a national quick-service chain...
4
In a move likely to intensify competition in the growing fun-and-food category, the private-equity firm L Catterton has invested in Punch Bowl Social, a six-unit contender. Terms were not disclosed,...
5
Paul Damico and Kat Cole have been shifted into new positions by Roark Capital and its Focus Brands holding for the rollout of Roark’s Naf Naf Grill fast-casual Middle Eastern concept. Damico has...
6
Sustainability has long been a trend influencing the industry, but it’s one that operators still need to consider today. Consumers are aware of what it means to eat sustainably—including using local...
7
Expect the unexpected—that’s the theme of the menu trends presentation during next month’s Restaurant Trends & Directions conference in Chicago. “The accelerated pace of demographic, cultural,...
8
In the struggle to pinpoint why restaurant traffic is falling, some Yoda types have cited increased competition from a gray area between restaurants and supermarkets—the place where alternatives like...
9
Customer traffic is among the biggest problems in today’s restaurant environment. In the face of the competition to bring guests in the door, operators are challenged with setting themselves apart...
10
After craveable food and beverages and well-trained staff, a hard-working menu runs a close third as a marketing and profitability tool. With shrinking margins and a growing competitive environment,...