

At this point, I don’t need to recap the cookie-brand news of the past couple weeks, but as a quick refresher: Crumbl is showing a lot of cracks, and Chip City has completely shut down.
So do consumers just not want sweet treats anymore?
I’ll be honest, while I knew Crumbl in particular wasn’t doing so hot, I was surprised to realize other such chains were also losing steam. Technomic just released a snapshot look at the afternoon snack daypart, leading me to believe this specialized segment was doing just fine — after all, 12% of all limited-service occasions are for this daypart, and 54% of those visits are spontaneous.
Not only that, the top LSR chains visited for afternoon snacks are Auntie Anne’s, Cinnabon, and… Crumbl.
I looked at Technomic’s consumer data for those three brands, along with the other big snack chains, Krispy Kreme and Nothing Bundt Cakes. Sure enough, Crumbl scores below its peers on all five key performance indicators by as many as 6.3 percentage points, which comes on food quality.
All of Crumbl’s five biggest strengths are tied to either innovation or technology, and neither of those are a huge surprise. The brand’s whole deal (and one of franchisees’ biggest gripes) is that it comes out with a whole new menu every single week, so being 14 points ahead on “introduces new and exciting products” is practically the bare minimum expectation.
As far as technology goes, Co-founder Jason McGowan has a background in the tech industry, and Crumbl has accordingly embraced tech, third-party delivery, and social media.
But now for its weaknesses. Affordability is on this list, which doesn’t surprise me in the least. Of the five brands I looked at, it has the second-highest average check ($16.65) to Nothing Bundt Cakes ($28.55), which serves entire cakes that — bonus — people actually like (it’s more than 18 points ahead of its peers on food quality). Krispy Kreme’s average check is $13.70, and Auntie Anne’s and Cinnabon both come in around the $10 range.
Crumbl also scores low on “has an excellent reputation” and “ability to satisfy everyone in dining party,” but the biggest disappointment is its weakness in “variety of non-alcohol cold beverages” (11.5 points behind) and “overall beverage quality” (7.8 points behind).
As my colleague Jonathan Maze wrote last week, Crumbl invested a lot into a line of dirty sodas that ultimately did absolutely nothing for the chain’s sales. Seems it may have actually had a negative impact on a brand that really didn’t need to give consumers something else not to like.
All of this begs the question: What DO consumers like? Far and away the highest-ranking brand I’m looking at today is Nothing Bundt Cakes. It only has one weakness relative to the other four — “has advertising that makes me hungry” — and it’s only one point behind competitors here. Seems like it doesn’t need the advertising.
Nothing Bundt Cake’s strengths (it’s more than 20 points ahead of competitors on all of these metrics) include interior cleanliness, overall atmosphere and ambiance, appeal of limited-time or seasonal offers, décor, and online ordering experience.
The “secret” here seems pretty straightforward. Focus on the quality of your treat, rather than how it presents on social media. It’s OK to lean into LTOs, but not at the expense of quality perception, and not every single week. And don’t forget the thing Crumbl and Nothing Bundt Cakes both do very well: Make it easy for your guests to order from you.