Emerging Brands

The father may be gone, but his spirit looms large at The Sicilian Butcher

Founder Joey Maggiore created this casual-dining concept to honor his restaurateur father. The growing 7-unit chain gives a modern, interactive twist to red sauce Italian.
The five-foot charcuterie board called the Strada at The Sicilian Butcher. | Photo courtesy of The Sicilian Butcher

 

Tomaso Maggiore, when he was alive, used to joke that he taught Geronimo how to eat spaghetti.

“When he came to Arizona, there were no Italians but him,” laughs Tomaso’s son, Joey Maggiore, who grew up in his father’s now-closed Phoenix restaurant, Tomaso’s Italian Restaurant, which operated for more than 50 years.

The senior Maggiore’s restaurant was known for elevated Italian food, across all regions of Italy. But when Joey and his wife decided to do their own place, they wanted to honor the family’s roots in Sicily.

“My father came from a small town in Sicily. He made the American dream, and that was to come to America and never forget where you came from, but love what we do here,” he said. “I wanted him to have a taste of Sicily in his back yard.”

Joey launched The Sicilian Butcher in 2017 to honor his father, who died eight years ago at age 73 after a battle with lung cancer. It’s a casual-dining red sauce Italian concept with a playful, interactive spirit. 

All pastas and sauces are made fresh in each restaurant, and there are meatballs galore — from Sicilian style (Tomaso’s recipe with veal, prime beef, pork, sharp provolone, parmesan, herbed breadcrumbs and raisins), to Tony’s Steak (aged ribeye, roasted garlic, caramelized onion, sharp provolone and herbed breadcrumbs) or even eggplant (roasted eggplant, basil, parmesan, mozzarella and herbed breadcrumbs).

Guests can choose their pasta, sauce and balls. Or they can select from classic signature dishes like Lasagna Al Forno, Ravioli Cacio e Pepe, or Veal Piccata.

One of the hugely popular options is the five-foot Sicilian Strada Board onto which guests can select meats, cheeses, bruschetta, olives, crispy calamari and more. It’s a supersized charcuterie board that runs down the center of the table and priced per person. A similar option is available for desserts. Smaller groups can get a meatball or cannoli Ferris wheel.

All units also have a concept-within-a-concept with a separate entrance called The Sicilian Baker, offering the house-made cannolis, gelato and other desserts, which does a brisk to-go business.

Now there are seven locations of The Sicilian Butcher/Baker, in Arizona, Texas and Tennessee. Two more are under construction in Utah and are expected to open next year. All are company owned.

The bakery shares a space with the restaurant but has a separate entrance. | Photo courtesy of The Sicilian Butcher

The concept is owned by Savory Fund, a Salt Lake City-based private-equity firm that specializes in young, emerging brands. Savory invested after The Sicilian Butcher reached three units. 

The firm is known for keeping founders in place, and Joey said he remains in control of operations, though The Sicilian Butcher recently hired its first brand president: Nicole West, who was previously vice president of operations for Hi Noon Hospitality. She also spent a decade as CEO of New York Pizza Department and began her career with Hillstone Restaurant Group.

West said it’s sort of a full-circle moment. The Hillstone office was across the street from Tomaso’s. “When I needed a break and wanted to feel nurtured and fed, I’d go to Tomaso’s,” she said.

Now, at The Sicilian Butcher, West said she has the opportunity to pay that sense of hospitality forward.

“This isn’t a job, it’s a privilege,” she said. “People come into our restaurants for all kinds of reasons, whether it’s a wedding or an engagement.

“I had a family come in that was celebrating a graduation, and then another one that, unfortunately, was eating the last meal before their grandfather went into hospice. And, for whatever reason, these people chose us to come to and hopefully give them a memory that will provide them joy or comfort,” she said. “There’s an [insane] amount of trust in that.”

With an average check of about $40 per person, The Sicilian Butcher meets today’s budget weary consumer by giving them options. They can come for a feast, or they can sit at the bar (there’s an all-day Happy Hour) with a glass of wine and a few meatballs, or they can bring a box of cannolis to a dinner party.

“The old school trattorias in Italy are casual places where you can go five nights a week if you want to get a beautiful bowl of pasta, some great bread,” said Joey. “We wanted to do something that was very family driven, that you can go for lunch, dinner.”

Over the next year, Joey plans to elevate the menu a bit with more steak and seafood options, “for those who want it,” he said. “We’re not just a pasta house.”

The Sicilian Butcher/Baker is operated as part of The Maggiore Group, which includes multiple one-off brands, such as The Mexicano, The Italiano, Hash Kitchen and the more recently opened concept The Delicatessen, which opened last year.

Joey Maggiore (left) and father Tomaso Maggiore. | Photo courtesy of The Sicilian Butcher

It’s still very much a family operation, over which Tomaso still looms. Quite literally. 

On the walls at The Sicilian Butcher is a large black-and-white photo of Tomaso, rolling meatballs A cigarette hangs loosely in his mouth.

Tomaso wasn’t happy about the photo, Joey said. “He got all pissed off and yelled at me. He says, ‘You know, people are going to think I smoke in the kitchen.’ I says, ‘You do!’”

But Joey said it captured something about his father that was authentic, much like The Sicilian Butcher.

“He was a guy who was always in the kitchen,” he said. “He was old school, but he loved the brand, and he would start his day every day there with me, and we had amazing memories.”

Multimedia

Exclusive Content

Financing

For restaurants, and their lenders, a tough environment comes home to roost

Credit markets have tightened just as a bunch of loans come due and more lenders shy away from financing fast-food restaurants, setting up the worst financing environment since the Great Recession.

Marketing

How Torchy’s Tacos is rebuilding its marketing mojo

After a rocky expansion into new markets, the Austin-born chain brought in fresh marketing leadership, doubled down on community roots, and finally added nachos to the menu.

Food

A major menu refresh expands and elevates options for Topgolf guests

Behind the Menu: The eatertainment concept traded in old-school buffets for a catering menu with a modern mix of food and drink that satisfies every craving.

Trending

More from our partners