OPINIONFinancing

Here's when we knew things were different at Burger King

The Bottom Line: This week’s edition of the weekly restaurant finance newsletter looks at the fast-food chain’s refusal to match its competitors’ prices.
Burger King
Burger King's decision not to jump head-first into the value fray showed this era was different. | Photo courtesy of Burger King

This is from the weekly restaurant finance newsletter The Bottom Line. To get this in your inbox every Monday morning, click here.

Burger King is firing on all cylinders these days. The fast-food chain’s same-store sales rose 8.4% in the U.S. last quarter, outpacing competitors by about 1,000 basis points. As we wrote last week, it is no longer just a Whopper story, and even its kids’ meals are attracting more adults. 

We’ve certainly seen Burger King generate momentum before, only to lose it and go through the same sort of handwringing we saw in 2022 and 2023. But there are signs that this period is different, and the biggest such sign came last year, when McDonald’s lowered its prices on Extra Value Meals. 

Recall that McDonald’s convinced its franchisees to cut prices on bundled meals, to ensure that they cost 15% less than if customers bought all the items separately. Almost immediately, I figured this would put pressure on Burger King and Wendy’s to do something similar.

Burger King would have done that in the past, because that’s the type of thing the brand does. It was also a big discounter, rarely afraid to lower the price on its Whopper and other items to get some attention. And here was McDonald’s, about to go public with a broad-based price cut. 

McDonald’s has had some success with its Extra Value Meals. The company’s big problem on the value front has been some of its other offers.

But rather than match McDonald’s value meal discount, Burger King did nothing, opting to stick with its Duo and Trio meals, offering two items for $5 or three for $7. It will periodically do Whopper Wednesdays, giving loyalty members discounted Whoppers on Wednesdays for a limited time. And that was roughly it. 

Burger King’s marketing kept the focus on its quality, while operations efforts and remodels made the restaurant experience better. The value was there for consumers who needed it. But the company this year has shifts its focus to a higher-quality provider. It has worked thus far.

“We cannot engage in a race to the bottom,” Burger King President Tom Curtis said in an interview. “And we cannot react to what anybody’s doing and try to do the same thing because the initiative you work on is usually a two-year timeline.

“If you try to respond to somebody, anybody, whether it’s McDonald’s, Wendy’s, you name it, you’re probably not going to do something as compelling as the thing you worked two years on.”

This week’s financial news

Nelson Peltz does want to buy Wendy’s now that its stock price has plunged to appropriate depths.

McDonald’s franchisees are skeptical about hand-breaded chicken. Also, we took a deep dive into the company’s training efforts. And it is ending its FIFA World Cup partnership.  

We got an intimate look at the remodel of a Starbucks location in Snohomish, Washington, on the eve of the chain’s latest evidence that its comeback has taken root. I thoroughly enjoyed writing that one. 

Popeyes’ same-store sales have been in a difficult slump, prompting the company to change its marketing leadership. 

DoorDash has an agreement to buy Instacart. I am not convinced this will work out well for restaurants.

I wrote more about Crumbl, and whether discounts can reverse its sales problems. The early returns have been mixed. 

And now Dine Brands has swallowed a poison pill.

Cheesecake Factory had a weird week. Mostly good. But weird.

Number of the week

Wendy’s was steadily increasing its unit count for years, but its sales and traffic challenges have led to a number of closures. Those closures have accelerated this year. The brand has now closed a net of 300 locations since 2023.

Quote of the week

“These are not conditions Trian discovered, they are conditions Trian presided over. This is an offer by the company’s longest-tenured fiduciary to purchase, at the bottom, the consequences of his own disastrous tenure.” Blackwells Capital, a Wendy’s shareholder, referring to Nelson Peltz’s hedge fund, Trian Fund Management.

On the blog

I wrote about McDonald’s, DoorDash-Instacart, and Nelson Peltz. For all my blog posts, check out The Bottom Line.

On the podcasts

On A Deeper Dive I spoke with George Hiller about soda contracts. On The Week in Restaurants we talked about DoorDash, Wendy’s, Sweetgreen, and Popeyes. 

For questions, comments or story ideas, send me an email at jonathan.maze@informa.com. And follow me on Twitter at @jonathanmaze. And also LinkedIn. And TikTok.

Multimedia

Exclusive Content

Financing

For restaurants, and their lenders, a tough environment comes home to roost

Credit markets have tightened just as a bunch of loans come due and more lenders shy away from financing fast-food restaurants, setting up the worst financing environment since the Great Recession.

Marketing

How Torchy’s Tacos is rebuilding its marketing mojo

After a rocky expansion into new markets, the Austin-born chain brought in fresh marketing leadership, doubled down on community roots, and finally added nachos to the menu.

Food

A major menu refresh expands and elevates options for Topgolf guests

Behind the Menu: The eatertainment concept traded in old-school buffets for a catering menu with a modern mix of food and drink that satisfies every craving.

Trending

More from our partners