
Americans have a complicated relationship with food safety.
On the one hand, the topic has never been a bigger source of debate and conversation than now. During the second Trump administration and at the peak of the Make America Healthy Again movement, artificial colors and additives have been banned or restricted, the nutritional content of seed oils has been debated, and processed foods are under new scrutiny.
Not to mention the recent “Green Scare” summer when many Americans — up to 30%, according to data from the International Food Information Council — avoided buying lettuce because of the cyclospora foodborne illness outbreak.
In fact, almost one-quarter of Americans said they were refraining from consuming fresh produce entirely or reducing their intake while the 19,883 cyclospora cases were circulating this summer.
Ironically, before the cyclospora outbreak, which was one of the largest in decades, overall food safety confidence increased from 55% in 2025 to 62% in 2026, according to International Food Information Council data.
Food safety is largely invisible and taken for granted until something shines a spotlight on it, like an unusually bad foodborne illness outbreak tied to a high-profile brand like Chipotle (E. coli, 2016), McDonald’s (E. coli, 2024), or Taco Bell (cyclospora, 2026).
“Our food is not less safe. If anything, it's probably safer. It just doesn't feel like that right now,” Brian Schaneberg, executive director of the Institute for Food Safety and Health at the Illinois Institute of Technology, said.
The available survey data is inconclusive and often contradictory. According to recent research from supply chain tracking organization, GS1, people are starting to believe less in the efficacy of food recalls: 80% in 2026, down from 85% in 2025. While the vast majority of Americans still trust recalls, more than two-thirds of those surveyed said they avoided an entire food category following a recall, and 59% discarded recalled food even when their specific product was not affected.
So, how can Americans be more confident in the food supply while simultaneously becoming more alarmed by the things that happen when there is an outbreak?
“Science in general — not just food safety — is struggling to be trusted by the general population,” Schaneberg said. “When [an outbreak like cyclospora] is so heavily in the media, there could be the impression that we have unsafe food. But we’re one of the safest food-producing countries in the world.”
He added that, ironically, with the push toward healthier whole foods, there are actually more chances for pathogen outbreaks.
“If a bag of chips is recalled, it’s typically because of a hazard like a piece of metal or plastic that got into it, but with fresh produce, you can’t really test it and put it in hold to see if it will clear, because it will go bad,” Schaneberg said. “You’re just dealing with a higher risk in general. So, MAHA wants people to be healthier, but that means more risk in the food supply, so how do we get better?”
Aside from the unusually bad outbreak of cyclospora, food safety experts agree that the summer of the foodborne illness was not abnormal. It just seems particularly bad because on top of the cyclospora in lettuce, other recent recalls included jalapenos because of salmonella, blueberries for E. coli, and soft cheeses due to listeria. So far in 2026, there have been 21 major foodborne illness outbreaks — roughly the same rate of the 26 outbreaks the FDA counted throughout 2025.
If that sounds like a lot — both in 2025 and 2026 — you’re not imagining things. There appear to be more foodborne illness outbreaks than there used to be after the passage of the Food Safety Modernization Act in 2011, during the first Obama administration. It gave the FDA the power to mandate product recalls as-needed, instead of relying on companies to voluntarily recall their own products.
“The system is designed to be preventive, which is why we might see a lot more recalls than we used to,” Schaneberg said. “If we do think there’s a problem, it’s better to take it off the market than to deal with the aftermath.”
On top of that, the food system itself has gotten more complicated as the FDA is charged with policing the safety of increasingly more ingredients every year.
“The more we add to the food system, it becomes almost impossible to catch up with all of them,” he added.
But if consumers only encounter the food safety system after an outbreak or recall, how are they supposed to develop confidence in everything that happens before that point?
This is where the questions around the food system become more nuanced. It isn’t just that our food safety protocols are perfect and the media magnifies a totally normal sequence of outbreaks.
“I think that the first question is, what can we do to actually prevent these problems at the source?” Dr. Retsef Levi, director of the Food Supply Chain Analytics and Sensing Initiative at the Massachusetts Institute of Technology, said. “Many would agree with me that we currently don't have sufficient surveillance at the source that allows us to detect these problems early before they arrive on the consumer’s plate.”
Levi said that with new remote surveillance and blockchain technologies, the agricultural system could be better monitored, and therefore problems could be more quickly caught at the source.
Currently, the tracing system is a lot murkier.
“Let’s say we trace something back to Arizona, but then what are you going to do, recall all the products coming out of the farms in Arizona?” Levi said. “People have to understand these food safety incidents don't only have a health toll; they also have a direct and significant economic toll.”
Given the current abilities of technology like field testing and remote sensors, it takes the FDA much longer than it should to trace outbreaks when they happen.
“Technology can help. Data can help. Processes can help. But at the end of the day, we need to have a strong fundamental culture of food safety,” Levi said.
Farmers monitoring the safety of their own crops might not sound directly relevant to the average restaurant operator. After all, restaurants are deep in the trenches every day worried about who’s on the next shift and how to preserve their already thin margins.
But just because restaurants are downstream from the source of a foodborne illness outbreak, does not mean they are helpless.
Some restaurants like Fogo de Chão choose to invest in blockchain tracing technology, so they can track each piece of meat from farm to plate.
But this is the exception, and most restaurant brands cannot afford such an expensive investment.
Building trust with guests and communicating with suppliers are two of the best weapons restaurant operators have against both the perception of and risk from potential foodborne illness outbreaks.
One restaurant chain, Breadless, known for creating “sandwiches” using hearty, leafy greens, took that responsibility toward their guests seriously, even if the cyclospora outbreak only impacted iceberg lettuce — which is not found on their menus.
“If there's anything out there implying salad greens are dangerous, then naturally that’s going to raise questions,” Marc Howland, CEO of Breadless, said. “Whether or not Breadless specifically carried those products is irrelevant to the sentiment.”
So, during the height of the outbreak, Breadless took a “proactive approach” and sent communications out to guests explaining that this outbreak affected prewashed bagged greens and that their produce was sourced fresh and thoroughly inspected in-house.
“We still told people we were going to consistently monitor the situation,” he said. “You can’t just assume people are going to trust you — that has to be earned over time.”
The cyclospora outbreak this summer is a rare event that most operators won’t experience more than once or twice during their restaurant’s lifetime. That’s why it’s important to not just be reactive, and to forge strong relationships with trustworthy suppliers. Howland said that Breadless works with regional farms, knows exactly where its produce is coming from, and then cleans and stores each leafy green in a temperature-controlled environment.
“I think being able to trace your food back to its origin, ensuring there are as few hands touching or processing it along the way as possible, and then handling it carefully so it’s clean and ready for consumption is crucial,” he said.
Restaurants like Breadless can't control the national conversation around food safety, but they can control how much their customers trust their role in the supply chain.