OPINIONTechnology

4 big questions about the DoorDash-Instacart deal

Tech Check: The proposed $17 billion acquisition could reshape the delivery business, from mom-and-pop restaurants on up to Amazon. Here's a stab at sorting it all out.
The deal would make DoorDash the clear leader in delivery. | Photo: Shutterstock

DoorDash’s deal to buy Instacart is shaping up to be a milestone moment for delivery. If the proposed $17 billion acquisition goes through, it will solidify DoorDash as the dominant U.S. delivery provider, in league with Amazon and Walmart, and put even more distance between itself and Uber Eats. 

It’s the sort of earthquake event that sends one’s mind racing in multiple directions at once. There are so many stakeholders and story lines, and so much we don’t know, and won’t know for a while: The deal may not close until early 2028, basically an eternity from now. 

So at the moment, we’re mostly left with a lot of questions. 

Here are four that have me closest to the edge of my seat, along with my best guess at the answers. 

Will this even happen?

The deal between two delivery superpowers is expected to face close regulatory scrutiny and is already being labeled a monopoly by some critics.  

The concerns are understandable. There are only a few companies that offer a third-party grocery delivery marketplace in the U.S. DoorDash and Insacart are likely the biggest, and together would account for 77% of the overall delivery app market, according to spending data from Consumer Edge.

Also recall that DoorDash and Instacart scrapped a possible acquisition in 2021 in part due to these very same concerns. 

However, that was during the Biden administration, which was tough on corporate dealmaking. DoorDash seems to think it’ll have a better chance under President Trump, whose administration has been friendlier to M&A.

Asked about the issue on an earnings call last week, DoorDash CEO Tony Xu said the deal is fair because it will give small grocers a better chance at competing with large companies like Amazon and Walmart, which will in turn help grow local economies. 

Still, it appears that DoorDash is preparing for a rigorous review: It does not expect the deal to close until late 2027 or the first half of 2028. 

My verdict: The deal gets the go-ahead, given the existence of other grocery delivery competition from Amazon, Walmart, Kroger, and Target. But there could be surprises if this lingers into 2028, an election year.

What will it mean for restaurants?

The most important question for this audience is also probably the hardest to answer at this point, because there are so many potential outcomes.

There are justifiable concerns about how an increasingly dominant DoorDash might throw its weight around the restaurant industry. If it becomes the super app, restaurants might have to choose between accepting its terms or losing out on a cartload of customers. And they may find themselves jockeying more closely with grocery stores for meal occasions, since they’ll all be jammed together on one app.  

By the same token, a combined DoorDash-Instacart could amplify some of the benefits DoorDash already offers restaurants, particularly a large audience. The company has said that restaurants will be cross-listed on the Instacart app, giving them access to new potential customers. As of last year, more than 25 million Americans and Canadians actively used Instacart.

DoorDash said it will also allow customers to combine their Instacart and DoorDash memberships into one subscription, which could lead them to spend more with both services. And bringing Instacart’s couriers (known as shoppers) into the DoorDash network could also boost the driver supply, which could improve delivery times. 

DoorDash is projecting $500 million in eventual annual synergies from the deal, some of which it plans to reinvest into its business. That could theoretically lead to better services or lower costs for restaurants, but will DoorDash have any incentive to do that?

My verdict: Despite some possible benefits, a more dominant DoorDash will give restaurants less flexibility in how they manage their delivery business overall.

Will Amazon respond?

DoorDash’s bid to buy Instacart officially puts it on Walmart and Amazon’s turf. They are the two largest grocers in the U.S. and have large grocery delivery businesses.

Walmart, perhaps anticipating such a deal, went on the offensive this summer by pushing into restaurant delivery. And it could be a serious competitor: Walmart has a delivery network that can now reach about 60% of the population in 30 minutes or less, as well as existing relationships with major brands like Subway and Dunkin.

Then there’s Amazon. The company dominates e-commerce in the U.S. and claims to be the country’s second-largest grocer via its Amazon Fresh and Whole Foods channels.

While Amazon is known for fast shipping, it has been working to go even faster in order to keep up with companies like DoorDash. In May, it launched Amazon Now, promising delivery of groceries and other essentials in 30 minutes or less. It planned to extend the service to tens of millions of customers by the end of this year.

Amazon has some history in the restaurant space. It started its own restaurant delivery service in 2015 but wound it down in 2019, in part to focus more on groceries. It has since gone the partnership route to restaurant delivery with Grubhub. Prime members can get a free Grubhub+ subscription, and customers can also place Grubhub orders directly within the Amazon app.

My verdict: With DoorDash and Walmart hot on its heels, Amazon will step up its restaurant delivery game, either with Amazon Now, the Grubhub connection, or both.

How will this impact Uber and Grubhub?

Amazon and Walmart appear to be the big targets here. But DoorDash-Instacart would deal a blow to DoorDash’s restaurant delivery rivals as well. 

Uber, of course, also apparently looked into buying Instacart, a marriage that could have tilted the delivery landscape in a different direction. Per the Consumer Edge data, Uber/Instacart would hold 36% of delivery app share compared to DoorDash’s 59%. Instead, it’s shaping up to be DoorDash/Instacart 77%, Uber Eats 18%. That’s a brutal swing.

Not only that, but Instacart has ties to both Uber Eats and Grubhub that will presumably be cut when DoorDash takes over.

Since 2024, Instacart users have been able to order from Uber Eats restaurants on the app, with delivery powered by Uber Eats. Uber has not said much about the partnership, but there’s reason to believe it has been good for its business. An Oppenheimer survey from late 2024, for instance, found that 82% of Instacart customers were also using the app to order from restaurants. That’s a valuable channel for Uber Eats to cede to DoorDash.

Grubhub, meanwhile, teamed up with Instacart last year to offer Instacart’s grocery selection on the Grubhub app. It gave an instant boost to Grubhub’s grocery business, which had been lagging behind DoorDash and Uber Eats.

I assume DoorDash would put the kibosh on that partnership, although DoorDash and Grubhub have become a bit cozier recently. DoorDash last month made a $125 million investment into Grubhub owner Wonder as part of a long-term strategic partnership between the two delivery companies. 

My verdict: This looks worse for Uber, but both delivery rivals could soon be eating DoorDash’s dust.

Multimedia

Exclusive Content

Financing

For restaurants, and their lenders, a tough environment comes home to roost

Credit markets have tightened just as a bunch of loans come due and more lenders shy away from financing fast-food restaurants, setting up the worst financing environment since the Great Recession.

Marketing

How Torchy’s Tacos is rebuilding its marketing mojo

After a rocky expansion into new markets, the Austin-born chain brought in fresh marketing leadership, doubled down on community roots, and finally added nachos to the menu.

Food

A major menu refresh expands and elevates options for Topgolf guests

Behind the Menu: The eatertainment concept traded in old-school buffets for a catering menu with a modern mix of food and drink that satisfies every craving.

Trending

More from our partners