OPINIONWorkforce

Is the tip credit system discriminatory? It's complicated.

Government Watch: A lawsuit filed by former Chili's employees has brought renewed attention to the relationship between the subminimum wage, tipping culture, and workplace race and sex discrimination.
Is the tip credit connected to claims of harassment? | Credit: Shutterstock

Earlier this month, three former New York City Chili’s servers filed a lawsuit against Brinker International, describing a “hostile environment” where the three plaintiffs (two of whom were women of color) had to endure customers constantly harassing them, making sexual innuendos, and commenting on their bodies. The former employees claimed that their managers “did nothing” when they brought up their concerns and even took away shifts as their customer ratings scores dropped. 

The plaintiffs, however, are not only filing gender and racial discrimination claims against their former employer — they are also claiming that Brinker’s tip credit policy led to the creation of a discriminatory work environment. 

According to the plaintiffs, this is not just an isolated incident, especially as it’s a proposed class action lawsuit. The filing claims that by leaning on the subminimum wage — which in New York City, allows employers to pay tipped employees up to $5.65 per hour less than the standard $17 minimum wage, assuming the rest is made up in tips — Chili’s forces employees to endure harassment from guests to make the tips that round out the rest of their hourly minimum wage. 

Of course, the tip credit is not a Chili’s-specific policy, nor is Brinker even in the minority when it comes to paying tipped employees a separate direct cash wage than non-tipped employees. The federal subminimum wage is $2.13, a full $5.12 less than the federal minimum wage. Additionally, 43 states, plus Washington, D.C., allow some form of tip credit, either following the federal policy or their own state policy. Only seven states (Alaska, California, Minnesota, Montana, Nevada, Oregon, and Washington) have completely banned the subminimum wage for tipped workers. 

Chili’s is not even the first major restaurant company to be sued for discrimination claims over its use of the tip credit. Olive Garden parent company Darden Restaurants was sued in 2021 by advocacy organization One Fair Wage, claiming that paying servers a subminimum wage is a violation of anti-discrimination regulations and that Darden employees are vulnerable to sexual harassment. The case was dismissed in 2024 due to lack of standing, because One Fair Wage did not have a direct stake in the case. 

One Fair Wage is also involved in the Chili’s lawsuit, but indirectly so this time. The advocacy organization held a press conference, publicized the lawsuit on behalf of the plaintiffs, and is supporting efforts to turn the lawsuit into a national class action. 

For years, One Fair Wage founder Saru Jayaraman has claimed that the subminimum wage is “a legacy of slavery” and that “tipped workers of color earn less than white tipped workers due to implicit customer bias.”

Many Democrat lawmakers have also called for phasing out the tip credit, though most have not gone so far as to evoke the legacy of slavery when challenging the fairness and legality of the subminimum wage. Two laws have recently been proposed that would end the tip credit: The Raise the Wage Act of 2025, which would both increase the federal minimum wage to $17 an hour and phase out the subminimum wage for tipped workers; and the Tipped Worker Protection Act, which would amend the Fair Labor Standards Act to repeal the subminimum wage. Essentially, advocates of these laws argue that the current federal tip credit is too low and that tipped workers deserve a “stable, predictable minimum wage with tips on top.”

Of course, the federal tip credit law does not mention discrimination, nor does it distinguish tipped workers by race or sex. But a facially neutral law can have unintended real-world economic consequences when it clashes with customer bias. And that is exactly what anti-tip credit advocates argue.

Predictably, the restaurant industry largely supports keeping the subminimum wage system in place. The National Restaurant Association has argued that not only does the tip credit help restaurants manage unwieldly labor costs, but many employees prefer the system more because it allegedly produces higher earnings potential for servers.

“People choose tipped restaurant jobs because they know the economics are in their favor,” Sean Kennedy, chief advocacy officer for the National Restaurant Association, said in 2024, responding to a different legislative effort to eliminate the tip credit. “Suggesting that eliminating the tip credit is better for all servers and bartenders, isn’t listening to severs and bartenders.”

According to the Chili’s lawsuit, however, employees felt that their employers were not listening to them when it comes to the proclaimed negative effects of the tip credit. With that case, the plaintiffs’ burden of proof is twofold. Jason Plowman, a hospitality industry attorney at Ogletree Deakins, said that they will have to prove that Brinker is to some degree responsible for the harassment they allegedly experienced, and also link the tip credit policy to the discriminatory environment they experienced. Additionally, Plowman said there are too many variables to argue for class action status:

“Arguing ‘This is what Bob the manager did to us, and here are the records I have of what was happening to me,’ is different than ‘I’m being treated this way and assume every Chili’s server should be treated this way across the country.’” 

If businesses must make up the rest of an employee’s wage not offset by tips, then do employees really have to endure harassment and discrimination if their paycheck is guaranteed to be supplemented, regardless of how much they are tipped?

“Their obligation is to pay the cash rate and make up the difference if the tips don't get them to the minimum wage, and beyond that I don’t think they are responsible for the issues with tipping culture,” Plowman said. “It’s basically a responsibility for implicit racism or sexism that we’re trying to place onto the employer. From a legal perspective, I don’t see where the potential liability is. Employers don’t control what their employees are tipped.” 

This is not to say that he thinks the former Chili’s employees don’t have a case. It just might not be a class action lawsuit against Brinker centered on the subminimum wage. Plowman zeroed in on the part of the lawsuit involving the customer rating system at this particular Chili’s, where employees were allegedly punished — including having shifts taken away — if they received low scores from customers.

“In hospitality, third-party harassment claims and discrimination claims should always be on the mind of employers,” he said, adding that the Equal Employment Opportunity Commission has issued guidance about not honoring discriminatory customer requests — such as asking for a female server or saying they don't want a Black server. 

“A lot of the facts in this case tie back to that concept,” he said. “If employees are getting disparate treatment internally from managers based on sex and race, then those concerns exist and are [legally provable] regardless of whether the tip credit issue comes into play.” 

Even if the tip credit disappeared tomorrow, sexism and racism within tipping culture would not necessarily disappear with it. And while employers cannot control how much a customer decides to tip a server, they can control how they respond to claims of a toxic workplace.

Back to the Brinker lawsuit: Assuming the allegations accurately represent the workplace atmosphere at that Chili’s in Queens, the server rating system raises a different question. If employees are penalized for low customer ratings, does the system make servers bear the consequences of their customers’ biases?

One could argue that this system perpetuates some of the problems critics see in tipping culture, like allowing a customer’s behavior to impact an employee’s status at work and earnings potential. If that’s true, then the problems extend far beyond a debate about the tip credit.

Contact Joanna at joanna.fantozzi@informa.com

Multimedia

Exclusive Content

Financing

For restaurants, and their lenders, a tough environment comes home to roost

Credit markets have tightened just as a bunch of loans come due and more lenders shy away from financing fast-food restaurants, setting up the worst financing environment since the Great Recession.

Marketing

How Torchy’s Tacos is rebuilding its marketing mojo

After a rocky expansion into new markets, the Austin-born chain brought in fresh marketing leadership, doubled down on community roots, and finally added nachos to the menu.

Food

A major menu refresh expands and elevates options for Topgolf guests

Behind the Menu: The eatertainment concept traded in old-school buffets for a catering menu with a modern mix of food and drink that satisfies every craving.

Trending

More from our partners