Pizza’s next play

Two fast casuals aim to flip the pie into the future.
posh tomato pizza

Build-your-own pizza is powering fast-casual growth—a trend backed by Restaurant Business’ latest Future 50 ranking. Three of the top five fastest-growing small chains were fast-casual customizable pizza concepts, shows the data compiled by researcher Technomic.

Although these operations have proven formulas for success, all are fairly similar on the surface. They offer assembly-line ordering, a wide choice of toppings and super-hot ovens for speedy service.

Two emerging fast-casual players are betting on something a little different. Their position: Tapping into the legacy of mom-and-pop pizzerias, updating old-world flavors and formats and focusing on the experience along with speed and customization.

What’s old is new

The “&” in Washington, D.C.-based &pizza stands for connection. The concept patterns itself after a neighborhood-style pizza shop, tying its 13 locations together through store design, use of local ingredients and support of community charities, says CEO Michael Lastoria. At Technomic’s Restaurant Trends & Directions conference in June, Technomic EVP Darren Tristano said “serving the community is as important as serving food to today’s growth concepts.”

&pizza’s menu also tries to reimagine the pizza experience. For one, the pies are shaped into ovals instead of rounds or rectangles. Guests can choose traditional or gluten-free dough, but there’s also a proprietary ancient-grains crust, which now accounts for about 40 percent of orders, says Lastoria. The builds also take a detour from the norm. Guests can choose a spread such as red chickpea puree or tomato-olive pesto instead of sauce. At the end of the line are “finishes”—some cheffy, including fig Marsala and pickled red onions—which go on after the pizza is baked.

Lastoria says that most &pizza guests order a signature pie ($10) on the first visit; by the fifth visit, they are creating their own signatures. Like others in the market, pies are baked in two minutes. But instead of the fire-powered stone ovens found at a lot of fast-casual chains, &pizza uses a conveyor oven for consistency. “As we grow, we plan to reinvest in the product and our communities,” he says.

Thin is in

A crust the same thickness as a tortilla is the platform for Brooklyn, N.Y.-based Posh Tomato’s pizza. Co-founder Morris Sarway first sampled this style in Europe and convinced the shop owner to sell him the recipe. He and his brothers, partners in the fast casual, are banking on the pizza’s uniqueness to expand Posh Tomato from its current four locations.

“A typical 12-inch pizza uses a four-ounce ball of dough,” says Sarway. “We stretch a 3.17-ounce ball on a vertical sheeter into a 12-inch flat.” This is done in front of the customer, adding to the experience, he says. Then, patrons can customize a pie from a choice of 35 toppings.

Similarly, Posh Tomato skips the open-flame stone-deck ovens seen in other trendy chains. Its pizzas bake in three minutes in electric ovens, which cost less and are easier to install; this lowers the investment for franchisees, Sarway says. A commissary supplies the dough and sauce. “We want the business to run simply with a low margin of error,” he says. “All you have to do is turn on the oven.”

Today's top stories

1
One thing I’ve loved about writing this column over the past seven (!) years is that by using real reader-submitted questions, I am always learning new things, due to the complexity of running a...
2
Chipotle has finished rolling out its new “Smarter Pick Up Times” platform to all of its locations that offer digital ordering. Through “Smarter Pick Up Times,” the chain says it’s able to monitor...
3
Which Wich is making moves into the supermarket segment, as the chain announced a new partnership that will put units of fast-casual sandwich brand inside 15 Crossroads IGA stores nationwide. Five of...
4
Ambiance and service attributes—not food quality—have the most dramatic positive impact on consumers’ willingness to pay more at restaurants, according to a new study. The importance of ambiance and...
5
After selling pizza and burgers as the operations specialist for a multi-concept franchisee, John "J" Hedrick has moved to the Pei Wei fast-casual Asian chain as CEO. The concept, the little sister...
6
Restaurant Brands International, the parent company of Burger King and Tim Hortons , has agreed to add the Popeyes Louisiana fried chicken chain to its fold for $79 a share, or about $1.8 billion in...
7
The prototype for a new in-store Brazillian fast-casual chain will be part of a supermarket Whole Foods intends to re-open in May in midtown Atlanta, the grocer confirmed last week. Called Roast, the...
8
First impressions count. And for many of your potential customers, especially millennials, those initial impressions of your operation will be formed via a glimpse at your website. So, how can you...
9
Julia Stewart has resigned as CEO of IHOP and Applebee’s parent DineEquity after leading the franchisor for 16 years. Stewart will step down on March 1. Richard Dahl, DineEquity’s lead director, will...
10
After suffering a quarterly loss and a decline in same-store sales for all but one of its brands, Outback Steakhouse parent Bloomin’ Brands said it will close 43 underperforming restaurants. The four...