Bigger is not always better

Menus have limited space. Guests have limited attention spans. Kitchens have limited storage space and prep capabilities. Bottom line? Make the most of the space you've got.

I never met a menu I couldn't make smaller. A simple rule of thumb is that every menu item in a category must sell at least 3% of its category. That's right, 3%.

Take a look at the example below. The Sweetwater Catfish sells a mere 1.08% of the appetizer category...not enough to warrant a coveted place on the menu (or in the freezer).

You might be thinking...

"Great Aunt Millie's Sweetwater Catfish would have to go!"

And yes, maybe that special pasta that three of your regular customers order every time they come in. But trust me, they've gotta go — the menu items, not the customers, that is.

This doesn't mean that you can't occasionally offer the catfish as a special, or assure your regular customers that the pasta can be made upon request if the ingredients are on hand. Streamlining your menu and your mise en place (that's your line set up) makes sense from both an economic and ergonomic standpoint.

Take a few minutes to calculate each menu item's contribution to category sales in our automated spreadsheet . Just use the numbers from your POS machine. Remember, bigger is not always better.

Members help make our journalism possible. Become a Restaurant Business member today and unlock exclusive benefits, including unlimited access to all of our content. Sign up here.

Multimedia

Exclusive Content

Financing

Despite their complaints, customers keep flocking to Chipotle

The Bottom Line: The chain continued to be a juggernaut last quarter, with strong sales and traffic growth, despite frequent social media complaints about shrinkflation or other challenges.

Operations

Hitting resistance elsewhere, ghost kitchens and virtual concepts find a happy home in family dining

Reality Check: Old-guard chains are finding the alternative operations to be persistently effective side hustles.

Financing

The Tijuana Flats bankruptcy highlights the dangers of menu miscues

The Bottom Line: The fast-casual chain’s problems following new menu debuts in 2021 and 2022 show that adding new items isn’t always the right idea.

Trending

More from our partners