facebook pixal

Court settles In-N-Out’s beef with Smashburger

A judge found Smashburger’s marketing of the amount of beef in its Triple Double burger to be “literally false.”
Photograph: Shutterstock

In-N-Out Burgers’ long-standing beef with Smashburger over the Jollibee-owned chain’s marketing of its Triple Double burger came to an apparent conclusion Wednesday, with a California district court declaring the company’s advertising to be “literally false as a matter of law.”

Quick-service chain In-N-Out originally filed suit against fast casual Smashburger in August 2017, asserting that Smashburger’s Triple Double burger infringed on the trademark for In-N-Out’s Double-Double burger. A month later, In-N-Out added a complaint of false advertising to its lawsuit.

At issue was Smashburger’s claim that its Triple Double burger featured a “Classic Smash Beef build with triple the cheese & double the beef in every bite,” according to court documents.

An uncooked patty used in a Classic Smash burger weighs 5 ounces, while the Triple Double burger is made of two 2 ½-ounce beef patties.

“Therefore, the claim that the Triple Double burger contains ‘double the beef’ as compared to the Classic Smash burger is literally false on its face,” the court said.

Smashburger representatives did not respond to a request for comment from Restaurant Business.

Smashburger had claimed that the phrase “double the beef” referred to the number of layers of beef in the sandwich.

Furthermore, the court found that Smashburger’s false claim was material, meaning it would most certainly influence consumer purchasing decisions.

But In-N-Out was not successful in proving that Smashburger is a direct competitor.

“In-N-Out presents no sales or other evidence sufficient to establish injury as a result of Smashburger’s conduct,” the court concluded. “Accordingly, In-N-Out’s motion for summary judgment as to the injury element of its false advertising claim is denied.”

Members help make our journalism possible. Become a Restaurant Business member today and unlock exclusive benefits, including unlimited access to all of our content. Sign up here.


Exclusive Content


Zume Pizza and the folly of trying to replicate Amazon

Tech Check: The demise of the former delivery startup shows the dangers of pushing a good idea too far.

Emerging Brands

Longtime Applebee's and Panera operator gives Jinya Ramen Bar a try

Doherty Enterprises has signed on to bring the Asian concept to the Greater New York City area.


At Subway, a very public auction draws to a close

The Bottom Line: The company has reportedly narrowed its list of buyers and the price tag is down. But the deal is taking a while to get over the finish line, and here’s why.


More from our partners