NYC soda cap could prove a boon for bundlers, study finds

The web is buzzing over a just-released finding that New York City’s suspended ban of large soft drinks could encourage rather than temper soda consumption. Less publicized is the research’s indication that the ban could increase quick-service restaurants’ sales through a simple variation on a common marketing practice.

By offering two smaller soft drinks as a bundled order, restaurants stand to raise their revenues above what they’d get for a single drink that does not exceed the pending serving cap of 16 ounces, concluded a study reported on a science site called Plos One.

The prospect of selling multiple smaller drinks to skirt the ban on larger servings of sugared drinks has been regarded as a duh! by the restaurant community. The researchers behind the new study put that option to the test by offering students at University of California-San Diego a multitude of restaurant menus.

The first menu offered soft drinks in 16, 24 and 32-ounce servings. A second offered a 16-ounce drink, two bundled 12-ounce drinks, and two bundled 16-ounce drinks. A third offered just the 16-ounce option. The price was constant for servings of the same volume (i.e., the bundle of two 12-ounce drinks cost the same as the 24-ounce serving).

All 100 of the test subjects were directed to order off each menu, which was described as coming from a fast-food restaurant (the researchers said they took the prices from McDonald’s units in the area.) The respondents’ drink orders tended to be larger when they were presented with the bundled options, even though they could have had ordered the same volumes on Menu #1.

The researchers said they saw no difference in the behaviors of male and female respondents.

“Total business revenue was also higher when bundles rather than only small-sized drinks were sold,” noted the Plos One report.

 “Our research suggests that businesses have a strong incentive to offer bundles of soda when drink size is limited,” the researchers concluded. “Restricting larger-sized drinks may have the unintended consequence of increasing soda consumption rather than decreasing it.”

Members help make our journalism possible. Become a Restaurant Business member today and unlock exclusive benefits, including unlimited access to all of our content. Sign up here.

Multimedia

Exclusive Content

Food

Butter innovation spreads across menus

Behind the Menu: Restaurants are elevating butter with creative flavors, formats and service, proving that a simple ingredient can set a menu apart and add value.

Financing

Fat Brands has a debt problem

The Bottom Line: The owner of Fatburger went on a buying binge in 2020 and 2021. Five years later it is working furiously to generate cash and pay off debt. But the government shutdown is creating headaches.

Financing

McDonald's is making a big bet on its Extra Value Meals

The Bottom Line: The fast-food giant argues that its lower-priced combo meals will generate more customers and more sales over time, and profitability will follow. But costs aren’t exactly decreasing.

Trending

More from our partners